Jorge Quitério Search
Technology

A functional matrix for classifying technologies

Every technology performs a process on an operand. Crossing operands with processes gives a simple grid that supports technology scouting and the identification of gaps in a portfolio. Several technologies are classified as examples.

Classifying technologies is a strategic task. Gaps or overlaps in a technology portfolio cannot be identified without a way of placing technologies side by side. Classification by industry is of limited use: "aerospace" contains furnaces, databases and fuel cells.

MIT's Management of Technology programme presented a simple classification based on one observation: every technology performs a process on an operand. This article examines whether this two-question classification works for real technologies and what it shows about a portfolio.

The framework comes from Rias van Wyk, one of the pioneers of management of technology, who proposed in Technovation (1988) to describe technologies by the operand they act on and the process they perform. Van Wyk used three operands (matter, energy, information) and three processes (transform, transport, store). De Weck's Technology Roadmapping and Development (2022), the textbook of the MIT programme, extends the grid to 5 × 5. Similar function-based thinking appears in systems engineering, notably in the object-process methodology standardised as ISO/PAS 19450.

Operands and processes

The original 3 × 3 grid:

Transform Transport Store
Matter a steel furnace a pipeline a warehouse
Energy a power plant a transmission line a battery
Information a computer a communication network a database

The course adds two operands, value (money and other financial instruments) and living organisms, and two processes, exchange and control. The additions make room for whole industries the original could not place well: financial technology, which exchanges and stores value, and biotechnology, which transforms and controls living organisms.

An ordinary home already fills much of the grid. The refrigerator stores matter, the boiler transforms energy, the electricity meter and the wiring transport it, the router transports information, the thermostat controls energy, and a banking application on a phone exchanges value. The grid describes a household as readily as a company.

Classification examples

Some technologies are straightforward to classify. Cross-laminated timber, engineered wood panels for construction, transforms matter. Recombinant DNA controls living organisms. Others are not. Cloud computing transforms information (computing), transports it (networking), stores it (storage) and, through markets for compute capacity, arguably exchanges it as well. This is typical of platforms, which are bundles of technologies, and their strength comes from combining cells.

Applications

  • Scouting and gap analysis. Place an organisation's capabilities on the grid and its blind spots become visible. A company strong only in "transform information" depends on others for half its value chain.
  • Seeing where change happens. The course observed that many newer technologies sit in the added rows and columns, consistent with recent decades of rapid progress in finance, biotechnology and control systems.

The grid has limits: real products span several cells, and the boundaries are a matter of judgement. As a first approximation, the two questions are nevertheless effective.

The figure below applies the grid to several technologies. The claim is that two questions, "what does it act on?" and "what does it do to it?", are enough to place any technology, and that platforms can be recognised because they occupy several cells at once.

  1. Classical examples. Click "Battery", "Network" and "Steel furnace". Each lands in exactly one cell of the original 3 × 3 block.
  2. A platform. Click "Cloud computing". It lights up four cells along the information row, which is characteristic of a platform.
  3. The added rows. "Payment network" sits in the value row (transport and exchange), "Recombinant DNA" in living organisms. Neither fits the original grid.
  4. Mapping an organisation. Select the cells where an organisation has real capability. The readouts give the coverage and list the operands not addressed at all, which correspond to dependencies on external suppliers.

Robustness. The grid is a classification, so the right test is agreement: do different people put the same technology in the same cells? Classifying the listed technologies before viewing the placements shown gives a simple measure of agreement. Disagreement usually means the technology is a bundle that deserves to be split, which is itself useful information.

A 5 × 5 grid will not replace a technology strategy. It does make a portfolio discussion concrete by showing where the organisation has capability, where it depends on others and where new technologies are appearing. Gaps usually become visible quickly.

References

  1. R. J. van Wyk, "Management of technology: new frameworks", Technovation, 7(4), 341-351, 1988.
  2. ISO/PAS 19450:2015, Automation systems and integration - Object-Process Methodology.
  3. O. L. de Weck, Technology Roadmapping and Development: A Quantitative Approach to the Management of Technology, Springer, 2022.